top of page
Search

The Sad Story of the New York Mets

domjohnson2032
Oct 12, 2025
3 min read

Let's talk about the 2025 season for the New York Mets. After coming off what seemed like a fairytale season in 2024 where they were able to make it all the way to the NLCS but eventually lose to the World Series champion Los Angeles Dodgers, the Mets hoped to come into the new year with a new found confidence. Could they finally make it over the hump and beat out the powerhouse rival Philadelphia Phillies and win their first NL East division title in a decade?


Long story short, the answer is no, but let's dive into it.


The offseason was a rollercoaster for the New York Mets. Owner David Cohen and President of Baseball Operations David Stearns knew they needed to make a splash in the market to strike fear into their opponents and build a dynasty in Queens. The key to that dynasty was one man. Juan Soto.


Soto, a generational talent, was on the free agent market after concluding his 1 year contract with the cross-town rival to the Mets, the New York Yankees. Soto put up outstanding numbers in the Bronx and helped lead the Bombers to the 2024 World Series against Los Angeles. Although they came up short, it seemed as though Soto would remain a Yankee for the foreseeable future and help lead the Yankees to the promise land.

The New York Mets signed Juan Soto to a 15-year, $765 million contract leading to the 2025 season, making him the highest paid athlete in history.
The New York Mets signed Juan Soto to a 15-year, $765 million contract leading to the 2025 season, making him the highest paid athlete in history.

To the surprise of many, however, Cohen and Stearns were able to get the job done and sign Soto to a jaw-dropping contract of 15 years, $765 million. The Mets found their guy and they locked him in for a long time. To top it all off, they were able to bring back home-grown star first baseman Pete Alonso on a 1 year deal as well as bolster their pitching options with the additions of players such as Clay Holmes, a reliever (also former Yankee) converted to a starter, AJ Minter, a reliable left-handed option out of the bullpen, and Frankie Montas, a hard throwing starting pitcher with a slew of deceptive pitches.


The stage was set. The Mets were ready to make a run at the World Series, their first appearance since 2015.


Things actually looked promising to start the season for New York. Despite injuries plaguing the roster fairly early on by losing Minter, Montas, outfielder Jesse Winker, and utility infielder Nick Madrigal, they held the best record in baseball at one point, and held a solid record of 55-42 going into the All Star break. Everything was going according to plan.


Until the All Star break ended.


At the conclusion of the midsummer classic, the Mets went on an all time downfall. They posted a 28-37 record in the second half, lost their division title, and were stuck fighting to stay alive for the final NL Wild Card spot.


It all came down to game 162. In order to secure that spot, the Mets needed to not only beat the Miami Marlins, but they needed the Cincinnati Reds to lose to the Milwaukee Brewers. As the Mets game played on, the graphic flashed. The Reds had lost. All they needed now was a win and they were dancing to the postseason.

New York Mets shortstop Francisco Lindor embraces first baseman Pete Alonso after Alonso lined out to end the inning in a crucial at-bat against the Miami Marlins in the final game of the 2025 regular season. New York would go on to lose the game and miss out on a spot in the Postseason.
New York Mets shortstop Francisco Lindor embraces first baseman Pete Alonso after Alonso lined out to end the inning in a crucial at-bat against the Miami Marlins in the final game of the 2025 regular season. New York would go on to lose the game and miss out on a spot in the Postseason.

What do the Mets do? proceed to get shut out by Miami and sent home on an early vacation.


How did this all happen? Weren't the Mets supposed to be the next powerhouse of Major League Baseball? Yes, in theory.


It comes down to 3 simple reasons why the Mets fizzled out this season.


  1. Injuries. Players, especially key pitchers in the organization, could not stay healthy. This was the same case for young catcher Francisco Alvarez. Alvarez is a player that can ignite a roster and fire up a team with stellar play but he missed too much time due to injuries.

  2. Bullpen woes. The bullpen went from the best in baseball to the worst at a fiery pace. Even when the offense looked good, the bullpen arms couldn't get crucial outs which cost the team wins.

  3. Overall passion. It seemed as though this team kept giving up at important times, especially when going on long losing streaks.


To conclude, this season left Mets fans scratching their heads. Sloppy defense, poor decisions, and poor at-bats led to one of the most epic collapses in the history of the franchise. Hopefully, the organization can right the ship and steer the New York Mets back to October baseball and raise the first Championship banner since 1986.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page